The Kaatskeller

Small Plates

• The Kaatskeller Wood-Fired Bread and Butter5,00 USD

  Scratch-made flatbread from our wood fired oven. Fresh local farm butter. Kriemhild Dairy, Hamilton, NY

Pasture

• Skillet Meatballs11,00 USD

  Hand rolled grass-finished chuck, slowly stewed San Marzano tomatoes, Tonjes Dairy Farm ricotta, Agrarian Feast live micro basil. Slope Farms, East Meredith, NY

• Cider Wings11,00 USD

  Raw Catskill honey, apple cider, fresh herbs, local rye whiskey, Tonjes blue cheese wedge. Pepper sauce accompaniment. Catskill Organic Chicken Farm, Ferndale, NY

River

• Brook Trout Rillettes13,00 USD

  Smoked trout, local farmer cheese, minced red onion. Wood-fired flatbread & chipotle pepper accompaniment (Gluten Free upon request). Tonje's Dairy Farm, Calliccon, NY

• Wood-Fired Cedar Trout24,00 USD

  Butterflied native trout, dressed with Panko breadcrumbs, Parmigiano Reggiano, fresh herbs & lemon. Seasonal vegetable accompaniment (Gluten Free upon request). Beaverkill Trout Hatchery, Turnwood, NY

Garden / Market

• Chilled Cucumber Soup7,00 USD

  Organic cucumber, mint, lemon, Tonjes Dairy Buttermilk. Neversink Farm, Claryville, NY

• Kale Caesar11,00 USD

  Wood-fired organic curly kale, curried chickpeas, scratch made vegan Caesar dressing, vegan parmesan cheese (contains nuts). Somewhere In Time Farm, Parksville, NY

• Heirloom Tomato13,00 USD

  Local organic heirloom tomato, feta, Kalamata olives, red onion, fresh parsley, simple vinaigrette. Neversink Organic Farm, Claryville, NY

• Arugula, Apple10,00 USD

  Neversink Farm organic arugula, aged Calkins Farm Lida Gold hard cheese, local apple, raw walnut. Cider dressing (Vegan upon request). Calkins Creamery, Honesdale, PA

• Watercress, Orange10,00 USD

  Organic watercress, lettuce mix, red onion, orange, wild fennel pollen, house miso ginger vinaigrette. Neversink Organic Farm, Claryville, NY

Artisan Pizzas / 12"

Wood-fired with Sullivan County kiln dried Ash. Traditional Italian "OO" flour blended with organic New York milled wheat. Make it vegan! Make it gluten free! Substitute dairy cheese with vegan cheese or gluten free pizza crust +$3/each

• Margherita13,00 USD

  Tonjes Dairy Farm fresh mozzarella, authentic San Marzano tomato, Agrarian Feast live micro basil, olive oil

• My Italian Friend14,00 USD

  Freshly minced garlic, white onion, aged prosciutto, shaved Parmigiano Reggiano, San Marzano tomato, live basil, olive oil

• Waterfowl Folly15,00 USD

  Sautéed portobello mushroom, local ground duck with bacon, house made lacto-fermented kraut, Calkins Creamery horseradish cheese, radish shoots

• The Manor16,00 USD

  Neversink Farm arugula, roasted red pepper, aged prosciutto, fresh local mozzarella, San Marzano tomato, 10 year Modena balsamic vinegar

• Seasonal Entourage16,00 USD

  Local blueberries, Irving Farm co2ee rubbed ham, Dirty Girl Farm Chevre, lemon thyme, San Marzano tomato

• Wild One17,00 USD

  Wild Boar pepperoni, smoked mozzarella, shaved white onion, spicy Harissa spiked San Marzano tomato. Alderwood smoked sea salt. Catskill Provisions pepper infused raw honey accompaniment

• The White Album17,00 USD

  Housemade wild ramp kale pesto, bacon jam, Sherman Hill Farm Chevre, shaved Parmigiano Reggiano, fried egg, broccoli shoots

Custom Pizza

• 12" Wood-fired Rosso9,00 USD

  San Marzano tomato, oregano, garlic, olive oil

Select Toppings

• Dairy

  Whole milk shredded mozzarella, fresh local mozzarella, local ricotta, local Chevre, shaved Parmigiano Reggiano, sweet cream, organic egg

  • each3,00 USD

• Organic Vegetables2,00 USD

  Minced garlic, raw onion, micro basil, spinach, arugula, roasted red pepper, fresh green pepper, mushroom, olive, caper

  • (3)5,00 USD

• Meat / Fish

  Pepperoni, house meatballs, Hilly Acres Farm sausage, 200 day aged prosciutto, ground duck with bacon, anchovy

  • each3,00 USD

Desserts

• Small Batch Artisan Gelato5,00 USD

  Ask your server for today's flavors. Tonjes Dairy Farm, Callicoon, NY

Cocktails

House Cocktails Designed by Apotheke NYC

• Deal Closer11,00 USD

  Vodka, cucumber, mint, lime, agave, vanilla essence

• Sitting Buddha11,00 USD

  Vodka, lemongrass, pineapple, cilantro, ginger, lime agave

• Dr. Ruth11,00 USD

  Vodka, rosemary, strawberry, lime, agave, cider topper

• Gardener's Gimlet12,00 USD

  Vodka, fresh basil and mint muddled with juniper berries and black peppercorn, lemon, green chartreuse

• Kaatskill Collins12,00 USD

  Scotch, muddled blueberries, lemon, ginger beer float

• Pistachio Goldrush12,00 USD

  House-infused pistachio bourbon, Catskill Provisions raw honey, lemon, crushed pistachio rim

• Hemlock Negroni12,00 USD

  Hemlock-infused gin, Campari, Antica Vermouth

• Paid Vacation12,00 USD

  Tequila Blanco, hickory smoked pineapple, habanero bitters, muddled cucumber, lime

Beer

Draft

• Genesee Cream Ale, Genesee Brewing Co., Rochester, NY4,00 USD

  "Genny" Cream Ale

• Ball Lighting, Pilsner, Catskill Brewery, Livingston Manor, NY6,00 USD

  Light yet flavorful, refreshing beer that delivers more complexity than your average Pils

• Floodwatch, IPA Catskill Brewery, Livingston Manor, NY6,00 USD

  Good summer time IPA. Big citrus notes with mango and pine resin

• Trout Town Two Headed Stout, The Roscoe NY Beer Co., Roscoe, NY6,00 USD

  Extremely robust with notes of roasted barley and dark chocolate. Don't be scared, this stout is as smooth and creamy as it is dark

• Sloop Juice Bomb IPA, Sloop Brewing Co., Elizaville, NY8,00 USD

  Hazy, unfiltered IPA with aggressive citrus-hop character without the bitterness

Can

• Narragansett Shandy, Narragansett, Pawtucket, RI5,00 USD

  Shandy is the perfect thirst-quenching balance of gold medal Lager with Del 's lemonade

• S.W.A.G., Black Hog Brewing Co., Oxford, CT6,00 USD

  Refreshing American wheat ale with hints of citrus from fresh grapefruit peels and a light herbaceous pop from herbs

• Easy Rye Da, Black Hog Brewing Co., Oxford, CT6,00 USD

  Rye IPA with experimental Nugget and Summit hops. Easy drinking and hop forward with spice and sweet citrus flavor

• Daisy Cutter Pale Ale, Half Acre Beer Company, Chicago. IL8,00 USD

  Pale Ale chock-full of dank and aromatic hops

• Strawberry Gose, Black Hog Brewing Co., Oxford, CT8,00 USD

  Pink Himalayan salt, coriander, fresh organic strawberries

Bottle

• Barn Beer, NY Wild Ale, Plan Bee Farm Brewery, Poughkeepsie, NY

  • 375ml13,00 USD

Cider

Draft

• Bad Seed, Bad Seed Cider, Hudson, NY6,00 USD

  This flagship cider is extremely dry. Fermented with a with Sauvignon Blanc yeast

• Farm Flor, Graft Cider, Newburgh, NY7,00 USD

  A blend of wild brett fermented juicy young cider with funky and acidic foeder aged cider

Bottle

• Neversink Highlands, Aaron Burr, Wurtsboro, NY

  Crisp and tart with tropical and farm notes

  • 500ml28,00 USD

• Appinette, Aaron Burr, Wurtsboro, NY

  Champagne-like Traminette and cider blend. Grapefruit and lychee notes with a soft, slightly bitter finish

  • 750ml .33,00 USD

Wine

Glass

• Riesling, Bashakill Vineyards, Wurtsboro, NY8,00 USD

• Merlot, Bashakill Vineyards, Wurtsboro, NY8,00 USD

• Zum Martin Sepp Organic Rose8,00 USD

Bottle

• Pinot Noir, Eminence Road Farm Winery, Long Eddy, NY35,00 USD

  Raised in old French oak, whole cluster, foot crushed. Ripe vintage, deep cherry fruit

• Chardonnay, Eminence Road Farm Winery, Long Eddy, NY36,00 USD

  Unoaked, mineral-driven with notes of pear and marzipan

• Sparkling Cabernet Franc, Eminence Road Farm Winery, Long Eddy, NY38,00 USD

  Deep-colored sparkling rose. Unfiltered pet-nat style with velvety, dark fruit character