The Martinsville Tavern

Le recensioni di The Martinsville Tavern delle persone che hanno visitato e mangiato al ristorante. In base alla valutazione recente.

1. KD

   KevinD VIP

   New York6 recensioni

   1.0

   Visitato il giorno 22 marzo 2025

   1. Complessivo 1
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 4
   4. Atmosfera 2

   My wife and I eat at Martinsville Tavern often. This night we brought our two boys, a teenager and preteen. The place was packed, typical Saturday night. Even thou we had a reservation it took 20 or more minutes to be seated. This happens. The entrance was full of people waiting. Once seated the waitress took our order. She was polite. The person, who looked to be a manager, filled the water glasses by grabbing the glasses by the top of the rim. This is a turn off since I put my mouth on the rim to drink. In the future grab the glass by the bottom. Our table was next to the main aisle. At some point the waitstaff drop some glasses next to our table. I think the glasses were mostly full of water or melted ice from drinks. I was on the far side of the table, but my families' shoes and ankles got wet. Enough to be an annoyance to be wet while eating. My one son stood up to show me. The staff cleaned up the mess but never acknowledged us. We were never asked if we needed a towel or if we got wet or cut by the broken glass. They did not even want to make eye contact with us. Odd. A few minutes later my younger son noticed there were pieces of glass on his lap. Since he had a napkin on his lap, we used it to dump the glass on floor. No one was cut. We told our server that there was still glass on the floor because if was our son's lap. She apologized and we finished our dinner. We were not looking for a free meal but at no point did management address what happened. It was an unpleasant experience to be wet during dinner and wondering where else could there be glass. Management failed is their duty to address the situation and show proper hospitality. Part of being in food service is hospitality. There is no category for this when I got the OpenTable request for a review.
   

   È utile?

2. N

   Nora VIP

   New York70 recensioni

   4.0

   Visitato il giorno 22 marzo 2025

   1. Complessivo 4
   2. Cibo 4
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 3

   We were seated promptly. Wait staff is friendly and efficient.
   

   È utile?

3. J

   Joachim

   Atlantic City1 recensione

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 8 marzo 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   The restaurant had a nice atmosphere, great food and drinks
   

   È utile?

4. J

   Jane VIP

   New York19 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 7 marzo 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   The service staff is excellent. They're available to help when needed, but not intrusive. We came with a group of 9 and they were happy to give us individual checks - not every restaurant will do that. It makes our dining experience so much nicer. The food is delicious!
   

   È utile?

5. OT

   Utente OpenTable VIP

   New York18 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 2 marzo 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Excellent meal, start to finish. Classic dishes with creative flavors, nice strong cocktails & attentive service. We dined with friends & enjoyed the lively yet cozy vibe of the front dining room. This was our third visit and we‘ve never been disappointed.
   

   È utile?

6. R

   Robert

   New Jersey8 recensioni

   4.0

   Visitato il giorno 1 marzo 2025

   1. Complessivo 4
   2. Cibo 4
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Oysters were fresh and the horseradish cream was delicious. Broccoli rabe, sausage, tomatoes and peppers were perfectly cooked and seasoned. Rack of lamb was accompanied with a blackberry balsamic sauce whose acidity was a great contrast to the lamb. Perfectly medium rare. Service was impeccable as usual. Have hosted parties here from 2-15+ and have never been disappointed. Desserts could use an upgrade, but not bad.
   

   È utile?

7. OT

   Utente OpenTable

   New York2 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 23 febbraio 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Loved the food and the cozy set up in this restaurant.
   

   • 

   È utile?

8. A

   Adam

   New York3 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 22 febbraio 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 5
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Everything was pitch perfect, starting with my wife’s pre-dinner Bloody Mary and ending with the Warm Pecan Pie we shared for dessert. It was our first visit. We shall certainly be back. A simply terrific-looking place where the service and the food were both as excellent as the ambience.
   

   È utile?

9. N

   Nicole VIP

   New York28 recensioni

   5.0

   Visitato il giorno 22 febbraio 2025

   1. Complessivo 5
   2. Cibo 4
   3. Servizio 5
   4. Atmosfera 5

   Food was very good, delicious dessert and great service. Cool atmosphere.
   

   È utile?

10. M

    Michele VIP

    New York3 recensioni

    5.0

    Visitato il giorno 16 febbraio 2025

    1. Complessivo 5
    2. Cibo 4
    3. Servizio 5
    4. Atmosfera 4

    The specials were delicious (lobster bisque and scallops), but the guacamole and chips were a little boring and I prefer crispy brussel sprouts. It's a little too crowded in the dining room. My two-top was just too close to the other tables, so much so that I couldn't even take off/put on my jacket without hitting someone. The service was great, but it was hard for them to access our table.
    

    È utile?